What’s the Difference Between HDMI Cable and Component Cables
Putting aside picture quality, the reason you should use the HDMI cable is that it carries the HDCP signals, component does not. If the source device, say a cable box, looks for the HDCP handshake, and doesn’t get it, it Will not output an HD signal. So if you want to watch HBO in HD from a cable box, you have to use HDMI or DVI.
I use the component cables. Then again, I spent about $60 on them (gold plated ends, large conductors, thick shielding, etc) for both the video components and audio channels. And, I bought them a few years ago, before HDMI cables were even around. The difference in performance between top-end component video cables and HDMI cables is negligent. But, if you just use standard RCA cables – like the cheap ones the cable TV company gives you – you won’t get as good of quality as the HDMI cables.
As HDMI cable connections become more and more widely used, we are often asked: which is better, HDMI or component video? The answer, as it happens, is not cut-and-dried.
First, one note: everything said here is as applicable to DVI as to HDMI; DVI appears on fewer and fewer consumer electronic devices all the time, so isn’t as often asked about, but DVI and HDMI are essentially the same as one another, image-quality-wise. The principal differences are that HDMI carries audio as well as video, and uses a different type of connector, but both use the same encoding scheme, and that’s why a DVI source can be connected to an HDMI monitor, or vice versa, with a DVI/HDMI cable, with no intervening converter box.
The upshot of this article–in case you’re not inclined to read all the details–is that it’s very hard to predict whether an HDMI connection will produce a better or worse image than an analog component video connection. There will often be significant differences between the digital and the analog signals, but those differences are not inherent in the connection type and instead depend upon the characteristics of the source device (e.g., your DVD player) and the display device (e.g., your TV set). Why that is, however, requires a bit more discussion.
Several people a day are searching for an interconnection solution by trying to connect HDMI to Component outputs through a cable for their high-definition equipment. Unfortunately, this isn’t a matter of rearranging wires and having the right type of connector. There is a fundamental analog versus digital incompatibility problem similar to the upcoming digital broadcast TV switchover versus your current rabbit ears that receive analog broadcast signals. They aren’t compatible and leave people confused just like the poor fellow in the commercial.
Component video is based on an analog format. With analog signals, the voltage signal on the wire is in a wave format and how the wave changes in height is what is important. Theoretically it has an infinite number of values between zero and the maximum, somewhat like the variable windshield wipers I had on an old Thunderbird. With the HDMI or DVI format, these are based on digital signaling. Digital as you probably have heard, uses ones and zeros with a series of pulses all at the same height and they are either present or missing. At the other end, processing equipment reassembles the information. In a 4-bit binary coding, you can have 1 of 16 different values as 4 1′s and 0′s assembled as a group can have 16 different combinations. So equipment at the other end of the cable that is detecting signals and looking for analog sine waves would put out total gibberish if it just received pulses of 1′s and 0′s.
Some solutions are very easy. If an HDMI or DVI output is available on both boxes, use those. The difference between DVI and HDMI is that HDMI caries the audio in addition to the video signals. But DVI is just as good and other than the expense of an extra audio cable, that will solve your problem. If you were trying to use the Component outputs because you already had the HDMI port tied up, they make HDMI switch boxes that are fairly inexpensive where you can plug multiple HDMI cables in on one side with one output on the other.
Via component cables an analog signal is transfered. HDMI is digital. Among other things this has the following advantage: As long as the data is transferred correctly you have the perfect image data arriving at your TV. There won’t be a single pixel difference in what the ‘sending’ device puts out and what reaches your TV. Component signals (as all analog signals) can vary in quality and you can get disturbances.
So actually: At first glance HDMI cables might appear more expensive than component cables, but that’s not entirely true. For HDMI the requiered quality of the cable is related to the length you need. If you only need to cover a short distance (two or three meters) a cheap cable will give you the best possible result that could ever be achieved by any means … it’s digital … the cheap cable has no influence on the image quality … just like the network cable your computer uses to hook up to the inet has no influence on the image quality of videos you download / stream.
Of course this doesn’t mean component is bad: Among affordable analog video connections it’s probably by far the best, but HDMI just has the advantage of not having to care about the signal being unintentionally “affected” by outside influences during transfer. So if you can: HDMI is the better choice.
About the Author
Openbox S9 HD TV Picture Rolling Black and White
|
|
Antennas Direct DB8 Multidirectional HDTV Antenna $64.59 This powerful multidirectional HDTV antenna lets you receive over-the-air high-definition signals and features up to a 15.8dB gain for improved reception…. |
|
|
SVAT CV502-4CH-002 Web Ready 4 Channel H.264 500GB HDD DVR Security System with Smart Phone Access and 4 Indoor/Outdoor Hi-Res Night Vision CCD Surveillance Cameras $647.99 Feature-rich and easy to use, the SVAT CV502-4CH-002 complete DVR security system has been specifically designed with the do-it-yourself consumer in mind. This kit includes a four channel DVR with a built-in 500GB hard drive, four indoor/outdoor hi-res night vision CCD cameras, and all the accessories needed to start monitoring your property immediately. In addition, the interactive coaching menu … |
|
|
Hawk Eye Nature Cam $60.00 Originally designed for bird watching, customers are using it to keep an eye on deer, raccoons, and other wildlife as well as horses, goats, and other livestock, and pets; even koi, bees, and rattlesnakes. The Hawk Eye Nature Cam connects directly to televisions, computers, or other monitoring devices, giving users live, 24/7 real time viewing. Comes with infrared night vision, built in microphone… |
|
|
General Electric 22730 25-Watt 1900-Lumen Specialty A19 Incandescent Light Bulb, Pink $2.37 25 watt 120 volt A19 Medium Screw (E26) Base Transparent Pink Party Incandescent GE Light Bulb… |
|
|
Limesat Ultra USB PVR FTA Receiver $106.49 Universal Remote (Including FTA boxes) - USB 2.0 - Ethernet Port - RGB Component Video Output - RCA Composite Video Output - S-VIDEO Output - SPDIF Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround - DiSEqC Control Versions 1.0, 1.2 and USALS - Auto TP Update - Theme Sort - Channel Search - Channel Auto Tune - PVR Scheduling - USB PVR w/ Time shift - Parental Control - Fast Multi-Satellite Search - Multi-Channel Recall … |
|
|
EyeClops Mini Projector $99.99 Kids can project movies, video games, and more with the Eyeclops Mini Projector. Designed for ages eight and older, this portable digital projector fits in the palm of your hand and projects a screen size of up to 60 inches! All you need for big-screen excitement is a dark room and standard RCA cables to connect the Eyeclops to your favorite media player or game console. With an optional battery p… |
|
|
Digital Stream Analog Pass-through DTV Converter Box $44.95 Convert over-the-air digital signals so you can see them on your analog TV with this Digital-to-Analog Converter Box. Make the transition from analog to digital broadcasting with ease. The analog pass-through feature ensures that you will be able to receive signals from both analog and digital stations. New factory sealed item. Satisfaction Guaranteed. Ships immediately! What’s in the box Digita… |
|
|
Xbox 360 HDMI Cable $4.60 Handling up to 1080p resolution in a single wire, the Xbox 360® HDMI cable brings you HD entertainment in all its eye-popping glory. High-def movies and TV from Xbox LIVE and Netflix, plus all your favorite HD games, come through in picture perfect clarity. The full Dolby Digital 5.1 surround sound will make sure the house is a-rockin’…. |
|
|
HD Pro Component Cable for Wii $0.86 Brand New Wii HD Component Cable. This 3rd party high definition AV cable connects the console to most TVs with interlaced component video inputs including high definition ready TVs that support 480i and either 480p, 720p or 1080i component video signals. Look for HDTV support on Wii games packages. Movie playback is in 480i only. High definition ready television required to enable high definition… |
|
|
Xbox 360 Component HD AV Cable $4.55 MODEL- B4V-00004 VENDOR- MICROSOFT FEATURES- Xbox 360 Component Hi-Definitin AV Cable This connects gamers to the world of Xbox 360 games and graphics through high-definition and standard-definition connections…. |